When The Church Is At Its Best/Worst (Part Two: At Its Worst)

I have been using ChatGPT recently to help me do some research on church history. It's a handy tool. Previously, I typed in this question:

Throughout global church history, what has characterized the Christian church when it was most effectively acting as "salt of the earth" and "a city on a hill"?

Today, I typed in this question:

Throughout global church history, what has characterized the Christian church when it was least effectively acting as "salt of the earth" and "a city on a hill"?

ChatGPT responded this way - and I have to tell you, I think it's a pretty good overview. 

* * * * *

"Throughout global church history, there have been several periods when the Christian church has struggled to effectively act as "salt of the earth" and "a city on a hill"—terms from Jesus' Sermon on the Mount that denote the church’s calling to be a moral preservative in society and a beacon of light and hope. In these moments, the church has often failed to live up to its ideals and mission, typically due to factors such as complicity with power structures, corruption, and a failure to prioritize justice, mercy, and truth. Here are some key periods and characteristics of the church when it least effectively embodied its calling:

1. The Constantinian Shift (4th Century)

Characterized by Political Power and Compromise: The conversion of Emperor Constantine and the subsequent establishment of Christianity as the state religion of the Roman Empire marked a profound shift. The church became closely tied to political power, and this alignment often compromised its moral witness.

Failure to Be Salt and Light: In this period, the church’s role became increasingly institutionalized, and rather than being a prophetic voice against injustice, it became more concerned with maintaining its newfound status. The church was often complicit in the empire’s imperialistic goals, including military conquests and the persecution of non-Christians.

Ethical Shortcomings: The conversion of the empire didn’t lead to a radical transformation of society in the way Jesus had envisioned. Instead of being a countercultural witness, the church became entangled with the very systems of power and violence it was called to critique. This resulted in a church that sometimes condoned violence (e.g., against heretics and pagans) and overlooked the needs of the poor and oppressed.

2. The Medieval Church and the Crusades (11th-15th Centuries)

Characterized by Corruption, Power, and Violence: During the Middle Ages, the church wielded immense political and economic power, sometimes to the detriment of its moral integrity. The Crusades, in particular, are a stark example of the church failing to act as a "city on a hill" and instead becoming embroiled in violence and conquest.

Failure to Be Salt and Light: The Crusades were marketed as a way to "liberate" Jerusalem but were often fueled by political ambitions, greed, and a desire for power. The church sanctioned violence against Muslims, Jews, and even other Christians (such as during the Albigensian Crusade). This was a period when the church failed to embody Christ’s call to peace and love, instead using religious justifications for violent conquest.

Ethical Shortcomings: Corruption in the medieval church was rampant, with the sale of indulgences, nepotism, and the concentration of wealth in the hands of the clergy. This exploitation of power and resources undermined the church’s role as a moral and spiritual guide. The church's wealth and influence were often built on the backs of the poor and the oppressed.

3. The Inquisitions and Witch Hunts (12th-18th Centuries)

Characterized by Religious Intolerance and Persecution: During the Middle Ages and into the Early Modern period, the church, particularly the Roman Catholic Church, became involved in various inquisitions that sought to root out heresy, often through violent means. The infamous witch hunts of the 16th and 17th centuries also involved religious authorities sanctioning the execution of women accused of witchcraft.

Failure to Be Salt and Light: The church, rather than being a source of mercy and compassion, became a tool of fear and coercion. The Inquisitions, which targeted heretics, Jews, and others who deviated from the church’s teachings, were a dark chapter in church history. These actions ran contrary to the biblical teachings of love, justice, and mercy.

Ethical Shortcomings: The witch hunts and inquisitions were often driven by superstition, fear, and a desire to maintain ecclesiastical power, rather than genuine concern for the spiritual well-being of individuals. The church’s involvement in these persecutions resulted in the suffering and death of many innocent people, especially women, and demonstrated a profound moral failure.

4. Colonialism and Missionary Expansion (15th-20th Centuries)

Characterized by Exploitation and Cultural Imperialism: The church was often complicit in the European colonial expansion, with many missionaries accompanying colonial powers. In many cases, the spread of Christianity was closely linked with the domination and exploitation of indigenous peoples in Africa, Asia, and the Americas.

Failure to Be Salt and Light: Rather than being a voice for justice and mercy, the church sometimes became an instrument of colonial oppression. Christian missionaries, while often well-meaning, sometimes aligned themselves with colonial powers, and their efforts contributed to the subjugation of indigenous cultures and the exploitation of local resources.

Ethical Shortcomings: The church often failed to challenge the racial and cultural hierarchies imposed by colonialism, and sometimes supported systems that dehumanized indigenous populations. The church’s failure to question or resist the moral and ethical implications of colonialism tarnished its witness as a beacon of justice, peace, and reconciliation.

5. The Reformation and Religious Wars (16th-17th Centuries)

Characterized by Division and Violence: The Protestant Reformation brought about profound theological and political change, but it also led to bloody religious wars and conflicts between Catholics and Protestants. In many instances, the church failed to embody the unity and peace that Christ calls for, and instead became a source of division and violence.

Failure to Be Salt and Light: Rather than being a force for reconciliation, the church became a tool of sectarian violence. The Thirty Years’ War (1618–1648), which involved devastating battles between Protestant and Catholic factions, exemplifies this period when Christian divisions led to immense suffering and bloodshed. The church's failure to act as a unified witness to Christ’s love and peace deeply undermined its moral authority.

Ethical Shortcomings: Theologically driven violence and persecution were justified by both sides as they fought for religious dominance. The church’s inability to promote peace, forgiveness, and unity led to prolonged suffering, further eroding its ability to serve as a moral guide.

6. The Church's Complicity in Slavery (17th-19th Centuries)

Characterized by Silence and Justification of Injustice: In both the Americas and Europe, the church often remained silent or even justified the institution of slavery. Some theologians and church leaders used the Bible to support slavery, while others failed to speak out against it.

Failure to Be Salt and Light: The church’s failure to advocate for the abolition of slavery—especially in the context of the transatlantic slave trade—meant that it did not live up to its calling to speak out against systems of oppression. The church’s silence or complicity in this injustice undermined its credibility as a moral voice in society.

Ethical Shortcomings: Many Christian denominations, including the Anglican Church and the Southern Baptist Convention, initially supported slavery, citing scripture or the supposed economic necessity of the system. This failure to act with justice and mercy was a significant moral failure that caused immeasurable suffering and injustice.

7. The Church's Response to the Holocaust (20th Century)

Characterized by Silence and Inaction: During the rise of Nazi Germany and the Holocaust, the Christian church, particularly in Germany, often failed to stand up against the atrocities being committed. While some individuals and small groups spoke out, the institutional church remained largely silent or even complicit in the Nazi regime’s actions.

Failure to Be Salt and Light: The church’s inability to effectively oppose the Holocaust and its passive or active collaboration with the Nazi regime marked a dark period in the church's history. Many church leaders failed to condemn the genocide of Jews, Romani people, and other groups, and some even supported Hitler’s regime, rationalizing their silence.

Ethical Shortcomings: The failure to act decisively in the face of mass murder represented a profound moral collapse for many Christian communities. This period highlighted the danger of the church's alignment with power at the cost of justice and human dignity.

Key Characteristics of the Church’s Failures to Be "Salt" and "City on a Hill":

1. Complicity with Power and Corruption: The church's entanglement with political, economic, or military power often compromised its moral witness and its ability to act as a prophetic voice against injustice.

2. Religious Intolerance and Persecution: The church's role in persecuting heretics, minorities, and marginalized groups, especially during the Inquisitions and witch hunts, betrayed its calling to love and serve others.

3. Violence and Warfare: The church’s involvement in the Crusades, religious wars, and colonial conquests demonstrated a failure to embody the nonviolent, peacemaking principles of Christ.

4. Failure to Act for Social Justice: The church's silence or support for institutions like slavery and apartheid, and its failure to challenge systemic racism and inequality, severely undermined its witness as a force for justice and righteousness.

5. Ethical Blindness: In these periods, the church often turned a blind eye to moral imperatives, prioritizing its own interests or maintaining the status quo over advocating for truth, justice, and mercy.

In summary, the church has least effectively acted as "salt of the earth" and "a city on a hill" when it has been complicit in or silent about injustice, violence, and oppression, failing to live out the radical love, justice, and mercy that are central to the teachings of Christ. These periods highlight the dangers of the church becoming too entangled with worldly power and losing its prophetic voice.

* * * * *